Three suspects in Manteo theft also charged with Nags Head larceny

By on February 1, 2023

Police say the three people arrested used this Mercedes in the larceny case. (Manteo Police Department)

The three suspects charged with theft from a Manteo ABC store on the night of Jan. 27 are also facing charges involving larceny from the Ulta store in Nags Head as part of a reported spree that included a high- speed getaway attempt, responses from multiple law enforcement agencies and, ultimately, their being taken into custody around the OBX Bowling Center in Nags Head, according to police sources.

The three who were arrested and face charges in both towns are Shaquan Copeland, 29, of Portsmouth VA, Tynasia Smith, 26, of Norfolk, VA and Shaquilla Cuffee, 28, also of Norfolk.

According to Nags Head Police Chief Perry Hale, that department was alerted to theft at the Ulta store at about 6:30 p.m. and a little later, the suspects made their way to the Manteo ABC location. The Manteo Police incident report stated that at the ABC, they stole several bottles of alcohol valued at about $780.  Hale said that at Ulta, the suspects made off with perfume valued at nearly $15,000.

Shortly after 8 p.m., Hale said, the Nags Head Police Department was alerted that the suspects had returned again to the Ulta Store and when police tried to stop the vehicle, the suspects fled at a speed exceeding 125 miles an hour. Close to 10 p.m., Nags Head Police discovered the now abandoned vehicle, described as a 2008 silver Mercedes, around Driftwood St with apparently stolen items inside. According to Hale, Cuffee and Smith were later found and taken into custody at the OBX Bowling Center, with Copeland arrested near the same location shortly after.

Hale also said that the Nags Head Police seized the Mercedes and found items, including many personal hygiene products, that appeared to have been stolen from other locations.

According to the Manteo incident report, the three suspects face shoplifting charges in that town, with a secured bond of $5,000 each.  Hale said that Copeland is under a $60,000 bond, while Cuffee and Smith are both at $40,000. The Nags Head charges against the trio include larceny, possession of stolen goods and speeding to elude arrest.

In recounting the arrest of the suspects, Hale thanked the Southern Shores Police Department, the Kill Devil Hills Police Department and the Dare County Sheriff’s Department for their assistance.

SEE ALSO: Three suspects in Manteo ABC robbery arrested





Notice of Public Auction

The public will take notice that the Dare County Tourism Board, at its meeting of October 20, 2022, adopted Resolution 2022-5 authorizing the sale of surplus personal property by public auction.

Saturday, April 1, 2023.

6708 S. Croatan Highway

Nags Head, NC 27959

10am: Back of the House Auction – Complete Commercial Kitchen

Partial List: True refrigerators and coolers, Hatco drawer warmers, Hobart mixer, Vulcan, 6 & 10 burner gas ovens/stoves, Vulcan 2 basket gas fryer, Vulcan 2-door oven, stainless prep tables, DCS 6 burner LPAS range & oven, Hobart dishwasher, pots & pans & more.

2pm: Front of the House Auction – Selling Everything in the Building + Architectural Salvage by room

Partial List: Antique ships wheel chandelier, Nautical & pirate decor, sword & pistol displays, polyword tables & chairs, ship models, nautical lanterns, art, commercial bar equipment, tables and chairs, NC decoys, fish mounts, signal cannon, architectural salvage, Several bars, pirate bar & more.

Preview 3/31: 11 AM – 5 PM & Auction Day starting @ 9am
Online Absentee Bidding Catalog Closes: 3/31 @ 8pm
Catalog + Thousands of photos @ SSAOBX.HIBID.COM
Island Auction Co. (252)489-5513 – Jason P. Humphries, Auctioneer NCAL #8423
Visa / MC / Cash / Good Check – NC Sales Tax, 15% Buyers Premium


  • John Reston

    Two, ok, 3 ways off outer banks via automobile. These Mensa candidates still attempt two robberies and a getaway, and they get caught at the bowling alley?? These dudes did not abide.

    Virginia is ~not~ sending their finest.

    Thursday, Feb 2 @ 7:58 am
  • Dano

    Very stupid criminals. They seem to have a need for classy liquor and perfume. “Book’em!” 😉

    Thursday, Feb 2 @ 1:52 pm
  • Jeff Walker

    @John Reston Yeah the fact it took two hours for the cops to find their car ditched a few miles from where they sped off shows it really was the thieves’ own stupidity and lack of planning that did them in. They had more than enough time to leave before law enforcement got their act together.

    Thursday, Feb 2 @ 4:20 pm