By Kip Tabb | Outer Banks Voice on February 8, 2023
The goal of the Task Force is to keep the transportation corridor open on Hatteras and Ocracoke Islands. (NCDOT 2019 file photo)Almost two years after its first meeting in May 2021, the Outer Banks Highway 12 Task Force issued its final report at their Feb. 7 meeting. Outlining the preferred options to keep the NC12 transportation corridor open on Hatteras and Ocracoke Islands, the report identified six ‘hotspots’ from the area just south of the Basnight Bridge (the Canal Zone) to the ferry docks and NC12 on the north end of Ocracoke Island.
However, with the completion of the Jug Handle Bridge, which was originally included as a hotspot, the report noted that “No additional work was recommended.” As identified in the report, the five other hotspots are, from north to south, the Canal Zone, Avon, Buxton, Frisco/Hatteras Village and Ocracoke.
The Task Force included a broad spectrum of stakeholders, including Kym Hunter of the Southern Environmental Law Center (SELC), Dave Hallac, representing the Cape Hatteras National Seashore (CHNS), Rebekah Martin, Coastal NC National Wildlife Refuge Complex Project Leader and representatives from NCDOT, state and federal fisheries and elected officials.
The work of the task force was to put into writing concepts that could be presented to NCDOT and the Federal Highway Commission when funding is needed to move projects forward.
Interviewed after the meeting Bob Woodard, Chair of the Dare County Commissioners, explained that county officials had been having little success approaching the state for help addressing future hazards to the transportation corridor on Hatteras Island.
“We were hitting with dead ends with NCDOT. No disrespect to them. They needed a plan, and we didn’t have a plan,” he said.
There were three hotspots the task force report has identified as priorities: the northern end of Pea Island (Canal Zone) to the Pea Island Visitor Center; Buxton, identified as “the south end of …Avon…to the northern portion of Buxton Village;” and Frisco/Hatteras Village, described as “the western edge of Frisco to the eastern side of Hatteras Village.”
The hotspots are all located on Hatteras Island, reflecting the concerns that if NC12 on Hatteras Island is impassable, vehicular traffic to Hatteras Village and Ocracoke is restricted to what emergency ferries can provide.
The report identified short-term and long-term solutions. The short-term solution for the Canal Zone was for NCDOT to continue to clear the road of sand after storm events and rebuild the dunes.
The long-term solution called for a roughly seven-mile-long bridge in Pamlico Sound from the Basnight Bridge to the Visitors Center, the study’s authors noting that it “may be the most feasible solution considering highway vulnerability and cost.”
Building bridges in the sound bypassing the Buxton and Frisco hotspots to Hatteras Village hotspots was also recommended. For both areas, until the long-term bridge solutions can be put in place, the committee recommended that ongoing beach nourishment project continue.
Two of the hotspots in the report posed more complex issues with no clear long-term answers.
The Village of Avon has seen a significant increase in flooding recently, but as the report notes, there is no obvious answer. One potential solution would be to raise NC12 through the area prone to flooding, but the report notes that “could create other problems with drainage and flooding of adjacent areas.”
Beach nourishment was done last year, and it appears to be working as intended. Beach nourishment is the task force’s short and long-term solution, although the report includes there are stakeholder concerns about that as a long-term answer.
The report concludes the section by stating that “a new feasibility study would be needed to explore the long-term solutions.”
Perhaps no area of concern is as intractable, complex and expensive as Ocracoke Island.
“We probably spent as much time going back and forth over this as we did anything else that we did,” Dare County Manager Bobby Outten said.
Moving the dock to a new location has its own problems, including shallow water along the shoreline that would require a causeway to be built and environmentally sensitive areas that are also often used for hunting.
The road from the ferry dock has been overwashed and significantly damaged a number of times recently. Outten addressed that as well, noting that, “everybody understands likely we’re not going to be able to hold the road.”
And as Outten he stated in his remarks, consensus on a solution is hard to come by.
“The problem is we don’t have consensus among the subcommittee, the community, the county, the regulators, DOT, and all stakeholders involved as to where that should be and how that would work,” he said.
That view is reflected in the long-term solutions for Ocracoke in the report that notes the Hatteras/Ocraocke dock will either have to be relocated or a new route created, but makes no recommendation.
When the Outer Banks Highway Task Force was formed in 2019, there was concern about funding the projects. Although funding continues to be a hurdle, with the passage of the Bipartisan Infrastructure Act and other funding bills from Congress, committee members are optimistic that money would be available when needed.
“When we kicked this off several years ago, we couldn’t have known that this report would come out at a time when the funding would be available to the degree that we’re seeing right now,” USFW Project Leader Martin said. “I’m very optimistic that we’re going to be successful because we’ve put in this hard work to move forward and secure funding and the only thing I would say is Fish and Wildlife Service supports the report.”
Martin’s support for the report was echoed by SELC’s Hunter in remarks following the meeting.
“We’re all on the same page now,” she said.
Hunter was referring to the preferred alternatives that called for moving threatened sections of roadway onto bridges in the sound, something she noted the SELC had been arguing was needed for some time. She also suggested that the task force look at a potential $194 million pool of federal money for infrastructure projects. Those funds are separate from the $110 million grant that was recently awarded for the construction of the Alligator River Bridge.
“It does seem like we should be in a really good spot to get these competitive grants,” she told the committee.
And as CHNS Superintendent Hallac noted, the ideas in the Feb. 7 report do not represent final documents.
“I would urge folks not to get too caught up in details,” he said. “These are really conceptual plans.”
Comments
Steven
Overwash flooding is essential for the survival of a barrier island. It’s the dune lines that greatly increase erosion rates..
Let it flow..
pj
Another example of how dysfunctional government has become. C’mon man! The ONLY solution to fix the transportation problem has ALWAYS been, STILL is , and ALWAYS will be, a bridge (i:e Key West,Fla.)from the south end of the Basnight Bridge to Frisco with exits to the northern central and southern localities. D.O.T or our people need some new people if they STILL need a plan to figure that out. I find it mind boggling that plan does not exist already. I guess we probably need few more years of meetings and a few more studies to figure out that we need a dam plan. That plan for the bridge over sound from Basnight to Frisco should have been made many years ago or at the very LEAST been prepared while doing the jug handle planning. Seems to me if you are going to have all the equipment and infrastructure there for constructing the Jug bridge there in place it would make sense and be much more more economically friendly to continue on with the next phases if you will. So much for common sense. Of course even with a plan, good luck at getting it implemented with the current state of divided politics and the inevitable fight with environmental groups. A whole lot of pockets would have to be greased to even have a chance for approval. So to be real, the only real solution to fix the problem is never going to happen. Scraping sand after storms will have to do for the foreseeable future. But hey..on the bright side there’s going to be those who make a lot of money on doing studies on the subject!
Bill
Nature will have the final say. She will “fix” it on her own terms.
mother nature
Boss Basnight sent us lots of riches
now he’s gone to his reward
our friends in the old north state
up on their mountains and ridges
have foot the bill for years and years
are tired of building our bridges
Hatteras Island washin away
is more than we can bear
but ain’t no use in wailin
cause mother nature just don’t care
Ocracoke Island under water
sure can send a scare
but ain’t no call for frettin
cause mother nature just don’t care
Mark Jurkowitz | Outer Banks Voice
Is this a limerick?
Steven
All we need through Pea Island is a sand path, like how it was before a permanent corridor was installed. The path could shift as Mother Nature desired and never needed scraped off or repaired.
The benefit would be tenfold and help eliminate the total destruction from building on every lot while cutting down all the lots vegetation.
At this point it’s going to come down to ferry service only, which may also help with the over saturation of tourists on vacation.
.. If we could only back the demographic that was good for us.
Tourism board drove them out and away..