Tolson takes voluntary manslaughter plea deal in death of LeeAnn Fletcher

By on August 31, 2023

John (“Jay”) Tolson being led out of the courtroom after the plea agreement. (Photo credit: Mark Jurkowitz/OBV)

Four days after the start of John “Jay” Tolson’s second-degree murder trial in the July 2020 death of LeeAnn Fletcher, the two sides reached a plea agreement on Thursday, Aug. 31 that carries a sentence of 56-80 months for voluntary manslaughter. Given that the roughly three years Tolson has been in detention counts towards the sentence, the plea tacks on roughly another two to four years.

Fletcher, a 38-year-old mother of two, was found unresponsive in her Kitty Hawk home on July 22, 2020, and she died three days later. Tolson, a Hatteras Island resident, was arrested in Bangor, Maine in October 2020, after an autopsy report from the Virginia Medical Examiner’s office determined Fletcher’s cause of death was “complications of blunt force trauma to the head with hepatic cirrhosis with clinical hepatic failure contributing.”

Tolson’s arrest also followed a determined social media campaign by Fletcher’s friends and family, led by her first cousin and close friend Trisha Cahoon, that expressed concerns that law enforcement was not adequately investigating the case. The high-profile case also generated national media coverage.

The plea agreement came after two days of testimony from prosecution witnesses that was at times, contradictory, and also indicated there were no head wounds found on Fletcher nor blood at the scene when she was found in the bathtub of her home.

In an interview with the Voice, District 1 District Attorney General Jeff Cruden said that plea agreements are “always difficult,” adding that “obviously, it’s not something we would have done if the family wasn’t 100 percent behind it.”

Asked for his assessment of how the trial was going up until the plea bargain, Cruden stated that “I thought it was going well. There’s always an ebb and flow in the trial,” adding that sometimes witness testimony “doesn’t go the way you think [it’s] going to go.”

Entering the courtroom just before 9:50 a.m. on Aug. 31, Tolson, 32 seemed relaxed, smiling and chatting with defense counsel. In response to questions from Superior Court Judge Jeff Foster, he repeatedly acknowledged understanding the implications of the plea.

In addressing the court, Public Defender Christan Routten said that had the trial gotten to the point of calling defense witnesses, they would have included a forensic pathologist and a forensic neuropathologist who would have testified that Fletcher’s brain injury “did not match the actual presentation” from the prosecutors. In the end, she added, “it would have been a case of the jury deciding which expert they believed,” and Tolson was concerned about putting his fate in the hands of 12 strangers.

Routten added that she hoped the plea agreement would bring “some measure of closure and healing.”

Speaking to the court on behalf of Fletcher’s friends and family, a sobbing Trisha Cahoon declared that “LeeAnn’s life was taken, not just from her family but from the whole community.”

“If Jay [Tolson] had given or actually sought medical help for LeeAnn, we would not be here today,” she continued. “He did everything he could to clean up and hide what had happened. To me, this is horrible.”

Judge Foster expressed his condolences to Fletcher’s family and advised them that “any hatred or ill will you hold in your heart will not hurt Mr. Tolson,” but would only hurt them.

In addressing Tolson, Foster said the decision to accept the plea deal “in some way…shows compassion in your heart” for not taking the case to its conclusion.

Asked if he wanted to make any remarks, Tolson stayed silent for a few seconds, before saying, “I pray for peace.” Because he was speaking so softly, the phrase he uttered after that was virtually inaudible, although one courtroom observer said she heard the words “and closure in Jesus’ name,” follow the word “peace.”

Lead prosecutor Jennifer Bland speaking in court. (Photo credit: Mark Jurkowitz/OBV)

Once the plea agreement had been completed, Foster asked the prosecutors about a social media posting made the previous night on the subject of “Justice For LeeAnn,” the slogan of those advocating for a conviction in the case. Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Bland responded that the post was taken down shortly after publication.

Noting that he had heard comments in the courtroom that ignored his warning not to engage in advocacy while the trial was ongoing, Foster declared that “I’m incredibly disappointed, after the discussions we had…that these things still happened.” He also stated that they created “the risk of a mistrial.”

SEE ALSO: In Day Two of the Tolson murder trial, opening statements and prosecution witnesses

Jury seated on Day 1 of Tolson murder trial 




Barnhill Contracting Company will receive sealed proposals for Manns Harbor – EMS/Fire Facility (EMS-8), Kitty Hawk – EMS/Fire Facility (EMS-9), Manteo – Youth Center on January 09, 2024. Times to be given on via addendum #01. See the following SCOPE OF WORK: BP 100 – General Trades, BP 105 – Final Cleaning, BP 205 – Demolition, BP 390 – Turnkey Concrete, BP 400 – Turnkey Masonry, BP 500 – Turnkey Structural Steel & Misc. Steel, BP 505 – Light Gauge Metal Trusses, BP 740 – Roofing, BP750 – Siding, BP 790 – Caulking/Sealants, BP 800 – Turnkey Doors/Frames/Hardware/Toilet Specialties/Accessories/Division 10, BP 840 – Curtainwall/Storefront/Glass/Glazing, BP 925 – Drywall/Framing, BP 960 – Resilient Flooring/Carpet/Base/Epoxy, BP 980 – Acoustical Ceilings, BP 990 – Painting and Wall Coverings, BP 1230 – Finish Carpentry and Casework, BP 1250 – Window Treatments, BP 2100 – Fire Protection, BP 2200 – Plumbing, BP 2300 – HVAC, BP 2600 – Electrical, BP 3100 – Earthwork/Turnkey Site, BP 3213- Site Concrete, BP 3290 – Landscaping. Scopes of work may be added and/or deleted at the discretion of the Construction Manager.

Bid Location and Time: Bid opening will be held in the Barnhill Contracting Rocky Mount Training & GPS Technology Room: 800 Tiffany Bvld, Rocky Mount, NC 27804. Time is as follows: January 09, 2024 at 10:00am and 2:00pm. Times per packages to be given on via addendum #01.

Barnhill Contracting Company will receive, open, and read publicly all bids received in person in the Training & GPS Technology Room at the main office and listed with the virtual viewing at the link to be posted on Barnhill’s Plan Room.

Bids will not be accepted from bidders that are not pre-qualified. No facsimile or email submissions are permitted. Sealed bids are to be hand delivered to the bid opening location noted above or mailed Sealed Bids can be delivered before 9:00am the day of the bid to the Barnhill Contracting Company Office at 800 Tiffany Blvd., Suite 200 Rocky Mount, NC 27804. Attention “Clint Hardison.”

The pre-bid meeting will be held in Person & Zoom Meeting on December 06, 2023 at 10:00 am at the Barnhill Contracting’s Rocky Mount Main Conference Room: 800 Tiffany Bvld, Rocky Mount, NC 27804.

The pre-bid meeting link can be located on Barnhill’s online Building Division Plan Room ( and below. A preferred brand alternates meeting will be held via the same link at the end of the Prebid meeting.

Bid Documents can be viewed or downloaded through Barnhill’s online Building Division Plan Room ( after 12/04/2023.

All Bidders are strongly encouraged to include opportunities for HUB participation wherever possible in their respective Bid submission.  HUB participation is a part of this contract and must comply with all requirements set forth in the Bid Documents.

The Construction Manager and Owner reserve the right to add pre-qualified bidders. The Construction Manager and Owner reserve the right to reject any and all bids. Should you require additional direction, please call Barnhill Contracting Company, (Clint Hardison – 252-802-0740).

Clint Hardison is inviting you to a scheduled Zoom meeting.

Topic: Dare EMS – Phase 2 Pre-Bid Conference

Time: Dec 6, 2023 10:00 AM Eastern Time (US and Canada)

Join Zoom Meeting

Meeting ID: 823 9069 2985

One tap mobile

+17866351003,,82390692985# US (Miami)

+13126266799,,82390692985# US (Chicago)

Dial by your location

  • +1 786 635 1003 US (Miami)
  • +1 312 626 6799 US (Chicago)
  • +1 470 250 9358 US (Atlanta)
  • +1 646 518 9805 US (New York)
  • +1 346 248 7799 US (Houston)
  • +1 213 338 8477 US (Los Angeles)

Meeting ID: 823 9069 2985

Find your local number:

Join by SIP

Join by H.323

  • (US West)
  • (US East)

Meeting ID: 823 9069 2985




  • Travis

    Thanks for staying on top of this one, OBX Voice.

    It’s probably the best possible outcome for both sides. From what has been reported, it sounds like this was not a slam dunk case looking at it from either the perspective of the defense or prosecution. So maybe at the end of the trial he walks free or he goes to jail for much longer than was agreed in the plea arrangement. Tough call for everyone involved.

    Thursday, Aug 31 @ 3:47 pm
  • William Harrison

    This is ridiculous. I truly don’t agree in any way with this. How much time and money was wasted. So dishearting what our court system has become

    Thursday, Aug 31 @ 7:28 pm
  • Al l.

    A plea is offered by the state when they don’t have a strong enough case to make a conviction. The state knows a not guilty verdict is very possible so in trying to save face, the plea is offered. Kitty Hawk PD dropped the ball on this one from day one with amateur police work. Cahoon is ultimately the one that created the weak case and placed doubts in everyone’s minds. She was trying to get attention for herself and thus cost the conviction of second degree murder. She was even chastised by the judge for being a drama queen in court. Me personally, I don’t think he committed the crime, but only God knows the truth.

    Friday, Sep 1 @ 6:14 am
  • Mike Raphone

    Absolutely disgusting. This is just following along with what’s going on everywhere else. Soon, murder will be legal, too.

    Friday, Sep 1 @ 8:05 am
  • Jay

    Thanks Mark for covering the trial.

    I believe once the trial has begun all plea deals should be stopped. If the prosecution and defense cannot come to agreement before the trail then the trial should run it course. Innocent or guilty. It sounds like the prosecution did a very poor job when prosecution witnesses give contradictory testimony. RIP LeeAnn Fletcher.

    Friday, Sep 1 @ 9:23 am
  • Larry

    This is a terrible outcome all the way around. We fortunate to live in a small town with almost a zero murder rate. The down side to that ( if there is one ) is that the police departments have little to no experience is homicides and investigating them. It is unfortunate that the SBI was not brought in immediately to help with the investigation , but hopefully our departments will learn from this.

    Friday, Sep 1 @ 1:18 pm
  • Amanda S

    I’m devastated by the minuscule value given for my friend’s life.

    Friday, Sep 1 @ 5:34 pm
  • surf123

    Terrible decision. They have had him in jail for two years, I think, so why not go for the conviction. If you win he is going to get serious time, otherwise he walks with time served. Plea deals never work out for the family and friends of the victim. Judge Foster’s comments to the family and Tolson leave a lot to be desired. The family does not need to be lectured on how to move forward and Tolson does not need approval that he made the right move. The Dare County Justice system never disappoints if you want ridiculously low bail amounts and plea deals. I am truly sorry the family counted on the County Prosecutor’s to have their back and they ended up folding like a house of cards.

    Friday, Sep 1 @ 6:31 pm