By Kip Tabb | Outer Banks Voice on March 30, 2025
As a mitigation tool to protect homes and infrastructure, beach nourishment has worked well for the Outer Banks. But it does have problems, problems that Dare County Manager Bobby Outten addressed head-on in remarks to the North Carolina Coastal Resources Commission (CRC) at its Feb. 27 meeting.
“It’s no secret that over time the cost [of nourishment] is going up, and there’s no secret that over time, the sand sources are going away. There’s going to become a time where either you don’t have sand or you don’t have money,” said Outten, who is the chair of the Coastal Resources Advisory Commission (CRAC).
In his remarks to the CRC, Outten mentioned a possible alternative to the cycle of nourishment, although he stressed there was a way to go before a new means of stabilizing the beach can be applied.
“The presumption is it’s not something that is currently allowed,” Outten said.
Outten’s reference was to ShoreLock, a Florida company that claims it has created an all-natural product that looks like sand, feels like sand, and has no effect on the biodiversity of the beach, including nesting sea turtles. The product also has the ability to dramatically reduce the loss of sand from a beach, according to the company.
In an interview with the Voice, Blayne Ross, co-founder of ShoreLock with Troy Scott, the chief science officer, explained that the concept began when “Troy started thinking how do we work with water instead of against it?”
Scott, who is a microbiologist, developed what is described as a biopolymer, created primarily from “an extract from Sargassum, as well as some other plants,” Ross said.
As Ross explained the process, the extract bonds with the natural sand on the beach when wet, but the bond between the Shorelock product and sand is not solid. Ross described it as similar to Velcro “that is creating is a little bridge between the particles of sand…It’s allowing (sea)water to drain between them, and helps the water get back out into the ocean without carrying the sand particle away.”
A lab study of the product done by the University of Florida Particle and Engineering Lab in 2010 found the product worked as anticipated, concluded that the treated, “under layer begins to cause particles to adhere.” The study’s authors went on to describe “the cohesion, after the initial saltwater rinse and subsequent drying phases [as] significantly higher for the treated sand…”
The study also made a point of noting, “that the texture of the ShoreLock treated sand is almost indistinguishable from untreated sand…”
The product has undergone testing in the Caribbean, where permitting requirements are not nearly as complex as they are in the United States. “We had a very long run on a pilot in Jamaica. Ten years,” Ross said.
The project demonstrated the safety and effectiveness of the ShoreLock product, according to Ross.
“That particular project put on about 12 or 13 feet in width [to the beach]. It actually accreted sand, and it changed by about an elevation of, I think, 10 inches in height,” he said. “We’re really comfortable with the success rate of it and what it does, and how it does it, and the safety of it.”
Jamaica, and the Caribbean in general, although subject to tropical storms, are not considered high energy environments for ocean currents. “The daily grind of waves, Nor’Easters, and other systems are a lot different than a single storm,” Dr. Reide Corbett, Dean of the Coastal Studies Institute campus, told the Voice.
For Ross, testing the product in a high energy environment is an important step to introducing the product domestically.
“I think the conversation would be, whatever small pilot location that a state chooses to do this… I’m talking a couple thousand linear feet, not even a half a mile. You would do it in one little spot and see how it goes,” he said.
Unlike a nourished beach, the ShoreLock product is mixed with the sand by digging a trench and placing it in the trench. Because it is a natural product, it does require periodic maintenance, typically four times a year.
Nonetheless, it is significantly cheaper than nourishment. Because it has not been applied on a US beach, the cost is still uncertain. In a phone interview, Outten pointed to an estimated $500,000 per application as a guess, telling the Voice, “even over five years, that’s only two and a half million dollars, not $27 million.
The cost savings may not be its only advantage. If the product slows beach retreat, its ability to stretch out the nourishment timetable could be significant.
“A product like this would make it less expensive and make the sand that you have last longer, which are both benefits,” Outten said.
Ross, who is anxious to have the product tested in the US, nonetheless, is careful in talking about what ShoreLock can do.
“The goal here is to be able to provide a solution that helps mitigate the loss [of sand],” he said. “Nothing’s going to be a silver bullet. Nothing is going to solve everything.”
Although not yet tested in the US, at the February meeting, Outten outlined for the CRC what the next steps will be.
“We’ve asked [Division of Coastal Management] staff to talk about, how do you start the process of looking at a new technique or a new material…What information do you need,” he said. “How do we go about starting the process? All those things to see if this is something that we want…Then maybe we’re into something.”
Comments
Or
Just collect all the chippings from our chipping programs. Hire my company, Acme Dune Magic, and we’ll use our chips spreader to layer (fertilize) the current dunes every few months. In very little time you get new plant growth and a stabilized dune with more sand accreting in front. Takes no time. Very cheap. No chemicals.
Been pitching this for years. But the “engineers” oppose it bc they aren’t needed.
Wilson
Some people don’t want to solve the problem, they just want to continue spending money.
Paulsack
How about DARE and CURRITUCK county invest in a system that crushes all GLASS bottles into sand.
Millions of beer, wine and liquor bottles would be a great start.
Kathy
I think it’s worth a try pending studies. Has anyone personally checked the existing beaches treated with Shore Lock?
Seriously Mr. Outten?
Mr. Outten thinks that a $500,000 application happening 4 times per year amounts to $2.5 million over 5 years?
And they are going to go dig a trench in our beach 4 times a year to fill it with these magic beans? My god. We’re really that gullible.
TERESA ELROD
Can it cause harm to animals or children. Children and animals get sand in their mouths every day on the beach. I am sure some of it gets swallowed as well. Is it possible this product will do them harm in any way. This was not mentioned in the article.
Ted
Or – Man made dunes are the biggest reason why beaches disappear. The Ocean is prevented from doing what it is supposed to do. Instead, it is blocked by the dunes and claws the sand back into the ocean. Cape Lookout has no man made dunes and it has nice natural wide beaches. The Outer Banks are Migrating Barrier Islands. There is no possible way to “stabilize” them. The Marc Basnight Bridge will eventually be a bridge to nowhere because the Highway 12 Canal Zone on Pea Island will be Ocean.
Arthur Pewty
A guy trying to sell fake sand to a county that is made up of 99% real sand. And it’s not quite April Fools Day yet. Got to love it.
DS
Least not we forget our dune system was made back during the work era of the great depression. Remember we have an erosion problem, not a sea level rise problem. Lastly government only knows how to throw the LOTS of taxpayers money at something, which anyone can do. IE, they have to spend money to do a study to see if they need to do a study to spend money.
Dylan
An early April Fool’s prank, either way.
OBX Resident
Has anyone checked if Jordan Hennessy has ownership in ShoreLock. If so, I recommend the County pursue any and all contracts with ShoreLock. It would be a another good use of taxpayer money regardless of the return on investment.
WindyBill
To OR and Shorelock: We won’t know until we try it. So, let’s try them.
Travis
Great.
Frankensand.
I’m sure everything will be perfectly fine.
Mark Jurkowitz | Outer Banks Voice
Without endorsing your view, “Frankensand” is pretty good.
Luminous
Of course we can always improve on Mother Nature, especially when there’s money to be made. Just try it! What could go wrong?!
It’s just our beaches at stake here. Pfffft. They’ll recover from whatever we inflict on them a few centuries or millennia after we’re an extinct species, a point some seem to be determined to accelerate towards.
Golden Years
A lot of questionable ideas being floated in the halls of government these days, but this snake oil from Florida has to take the cake locally.
A ten year, unverifiable pilot in a foreign nation with lax regulatory environment? What could go wrong?
Tax savings for a county whose budget just increased by billions with 35,000 in population?
This should be sending up red flags and raising the alarm bell to anyone paying attention.
How about we just collectively realize that there isn’t any product or service that is going to hold the sand in place, and work with nature instead of against it? It costs nothing.
How about we realize that we have built structures in places that used to be inlets and wash over barrier islands? Realizing this costs nothing and could save us so much money instead of digging it into the sand.
“Islands of the shifting sands” ringing any bells to the long time leadership of this place?
Steven
Finally, someone else understands what is happening.
Thank you Ted!
Dune lines cause erosion, they are the reason Hatteras Island is being eaten.
Overwash must flow!
Tom Tenderly
To stop the beach erosion, something would have to be placed 3 or 4 hundred feet out to take the energy out of the waves in stormy weather. It is the energy of the water hitting the sand, loosening it and sweeping it out to sea that causes beach erosion. It’s not the perfect solution, but the only thing that will keep the sand on the beach and allow it to build up even more is to do something to take energy out of the waves before they slam the beaches. There are several ways this could be done. But, I’ve never heard any of the geniuses tasked with saving the beaches suggest anything like my idea. It would change things, for sure. But, the alternative is to continue losing beach until it’s just a memory.
Steven
Tom Tenderly,
Already in place is exactly what you describe, and there are at least two rows of them. First being the outer bar, second being a shoal, which can be numerous. These function to break down wave energy and are very effective.
Problem is with beach nourishment efforts, by pumping sand off these bars and shoals, their purpose and function is severely diminished.
D Q
If we’re already spending millions to shuffle sand around Oregon inlet a couple spoon fulls at the time to try and keep it navigable and apparently at the same time have a need to re nourish dare county beaches with sand. Why is the county and/or state not looking into some kind of permanent infrastructure or pump system that can harvest sand from Oregon inlet and send the spoil both north and south to town and hatteras island?
Justin Mason
Unfortunately, we will never stop the erosion…it’s been eroding since our sandbars turned into barrier islands hundreds of years ago. They are meant to “recycle” the sand change the face of the shoreline. When we started building houses on stilts, then started encroaching on the natural shoreline; we momentarily slowed down mother natures mission to renew and replenish. Wasting money on dredging is essentially throwing money in the toilet; this new “magic” method of bonding wet sand to sargasm (basically seaweed/algae) like someone said “magic beans”. I personally think this is the stupidest thing we could waste our communities money on. I also agree with another poster who said something about putting something further out to stop the natural onslaught. I know no one wants to hear the truth; but in my opinion there is nothing we can do to stop Mother Nature from redecorating her coastline. All we can do is get in her way until we either run out of sand, money, or bright ideas as someone else mentioned. It’s inevitable my fellow locals…inevitable, unavoidable, and non preventable.